Richard Sherman is America’s Dream and America’s Nightmare

By Joseph Mathews

“America is the greatest country in the world!” If you are an American and have red blood running through your veins you have heard this over and over again from the time you were old enough to breathe without an umbilical cord. Growing up in the patriotic Midwestern military town, Midwest City, Oklahoma, I heard this phrase more than the average kid. Like everyone else, at a young age it was impressed and ingrained in me that everything we engage in is competition and you are supposed to be the best at whatever you do. This is and always has been the American way because “we are America”. And “If you don’t agree with how we do things over here then you should leave”. As I have listened to the national discussion going on about Richard Sherman and his now “infamous” postgame response, I find myself just as amazed (not really) at the irony and double talk of those who reacted to his response.

You see the same people who responded so strongly to Richard Sherman by calling him a “thug” and “classless”, as he spoke about how great he was after the biggest play of his life are the same people who symbolically wrap themselves in the American flag of Patriotism singing Lee Greenwood songs like “Proud to be an American” as they gloat about how great this country is, and how great they are because they’re American. This is a belief grounded in America’s obsession with competition and domination of others in every way. This widely held belief is deeply embedded into the psyche of "not all" but many kids especially those with  white privilege from the time they enter this world. They’re taught that those who excel to the top should be bestowed with riches and spoils that come along with being the best or obtaining the most through competition. One of these spoils is the “privilege“ to be extremely proud, aka arrogant, about ones accomplishments. But Sherman, who participates in football, the ultimate “competition” which is truly an American value was not afforded that same privilege and freedom to express that he believes he is a superior competitor without public backlash. Instead, he was treated the opposite of what America says it stands for.

In the context of this country’s current social construct.  Sherman embodies the idea of what being an American is more than those who are his detractors. He puts many who have a problem with him in a conundrum because he is a mirror of America and what it represents. But on the other hand, subconsciously he’s something that they desire to be, but could not quite attain - the true essence of the “American Dream”.  Richard Sherman is a tall, dark, handsome, well-built, and athletic. America has always had an obsession with beauty. He is a great athlete, and we all know America’s obsession with sports. They say “he loves media attention”. Media has always been an American obsession too. They accused him of trying to get more attention so he can get more endorsements. This country is all about endorsements. They said “he’s in it for the fame”. If that is the case, he is no different than the reality TV stars that we pay millions of dollars for doing nothing. They say “He’s in it for the money”. Last time I checked this country loves money so much, we call ourselves Capitalist and worship money more than God. Regardless of how you may feel about him, you have to admit he is the ultimate competitor, a quality that America preaches, values and ingrains into its citizens from the time of birth.  Richard Sherman saying he believes “he is the best” because of his ability to dominate others in an American made sport doesn’t make him un-American. It makes him as American as American Pie. 

There is no question that all of the qualities that Richard Sherman has been demonstrating are American values. The problem is that these qualities are great as long as they are in the hands of persons whom America views as being “fully American” aka non-African Americans. The American dream quickly becomes a nightmare when it falls into the hands of people like Sherman – someone who is young, rich, talented...and black. As the old saying goes “it’s no fun when the rabbit has the gun”. See if one is aware of history, Richards’s bravado and claims to be the best are very reminiscent of a young big mouth cocky kid name Cassius Clay – later Mohamed Ali – who eventually became a national and world wide leader.  Historically, black athletes with extreme intellect like (i.e. Mohamed Ali, Jim Brown, Paul Robeson) were considered extremely controversial and scary to the establishment and those who subscribe to the idea that the American Dream is only for a certain group of people.

The biggest problem that not all but "some" white people have with this young man is that he is the embodiment of the American dream, manifested in a black man’s body, which to many in America, is a nightmare. When he said he was the best, he was talking about being the best NFL defensive back. But those infected with the disease of white supremacy just heard a young rich black male say “he was the best” and to those who subscribe to the ideology of white supremacy those are fighting words. In any other forum, contemporaries of young Mr. Sherman from a different race with his work ethic, intellect, educational attainment and talent would be touted as being quintessentially a wholesome “all-American” kid. But it still remains true that in this country, one of America's greatest nightmares is for young black athlete's such as Sherman and others to use their influence and platforms to speak forcefully because those willing to do so may eventually start doing so against injustice and inequality. With their platforms they would have the potential to mobilize the masses of young black males who look up to them, inspiring them to begin viewing themselves in a more positive light, causing a paradigm shift in the social order. This is the reason why this young man is so polarizing. They know Richard Sherman has the potential to be that athlete. And if they neutralize and vilify him and others like him before they can execute their potential then America’s Nightmare will never come to fruition.

In closing I want to personally speak to my brethren, who may have a problem with Richard Sherman and the success he has obtained. While I don’t agree with how this country goes about creating nightmares for some so that others can have the so-called American Dream under the disguise of Capitalism, I do feel that if you’re going to subscribe to these beliefs you should go back and listen to Lee Greenwood’s song again as it says “I’m proud to be an American, where at least I know I’m free!” and ask if this was meant for all of us or just for some? So don’t be jealous of Richard or others who have accomplished the American Dream without the comforts of privilege and often in the face of resistance. They have the freedom to do so just like you. And if this makes you mad, maybe you should revisit your Great American Dream hand book and re-read what you always said when you felt like you were on top and others were on the bottom:

“In this country you can become anything you want to become, because it’s the greatest country in the world and If you’re not living the America’s Dream,  just know that it’s not Americas fault, it’s your own, because you’re not working hard enough or you’re just not good enough. So go and pull yourself up by your own boot straps.”.

So y’all quit complaining about Richard Sherman and calling him names and go out there and work as hard as he did to get what he has. It’s all about competition - the American way remember?

“And if you don’t agree with how we do things over here then you should leave.” 

Please check out Mr. Lee Greenwoods song "Proud to be an American" being played at a Football game below:

 

Thug is the New "N" Word: The Criminalization of Richard Sherman and Black Youth

by Joseph Mathews

Thug - a tough and violent man; a criminal

It wasn't five minutes after I posted my thoughts on Facebook that many of my white childhood Facebook friends went in one me about him. Their comments were so full of hate I had to rewind my TiVo to make sure that I had not missed something, like him shooting or stabbing another player. As I began reminiscing about what it was like to be black and playing sports while growing up in Oklahoma, this country’s most conservative and what many would argue one of the most racist states in America, my memories were haunting. I have seen more than my share of young black males killed, incarcerated, discriminated against, harassed and criminalized in the name of being a thug, including myself. And the comments being made on my page represented the larger narrative going on simultaneously around the country and the feeling of many people in very low and high places.

Man! Richard I wish you would have told them that you graduated 2nd in your class from a high school in Compton and went to Stanford where you graduated with a 3.9 GPA! I wish you would have told them you were working on your Masters Degree! I wish you would have told them that you were not a thug but a hero to your hood because despite the odds, you accomplished your dreams! This is what I was thinking they should have had him saying as I sat in front of my TV and watched the Beats by Dre Head Phones commercial that set the stage for what was about to transpire around the country. During the NFC championship game between the Seattle Seahawks and the San Francisco 49ers, as the reporter on the commercial said to him “what do you think of being known as a thug around the league?" I shook my head as he just put his head phones on, because I knew what was coming. NFL defensive back Richard Sherman’s character was about to be assassinated, he was about to become the latest victim of the dreaded New N-Word “Thug”.

The racist venom reached a fever pitch after he gave the post-game interview. I watched as negative comment after negative comment poured in - every last one of them questioning his character and calling him every name in the book, stopping just short of calling him the “N” word. But the foundation had already been laid. They could not get away with calling him a no good “N” but they could get away with calling him a no good “Thug” which was the word of choice being used to characterize him nationally. Unlike the painful racially charged N-Word, which carries much historical baggage, the usage of the “T” word is not publicly frowned upon at all nor is it politically incorrect and in many cases its often used as a means for justifying the mistreatment and criminalization of black youth.

This guilty by characterization and classification mindset has been at the center of many recent racial controversies that have resulted in those who committed acts of violence against unarmed black youth being free to walk away, because in death the victim’s character was put on trial, and in life they were all found guilty of being thugs, which in the court of public opinion is punishable by death. You see no one really cares about what happens to kids that are not fully viewed as human beings, who are guilty of something. But I think it would be an insult to the intelligence of those who now know Richard Sherman’s background and continue to call him a thug. Because I truly believe that they believe he is not a thug. They know exactly what they are saying and where their hearts truly are. They understand very well that people are treated like they are viewed, and that historically the practice of stripping away young black males humanity, through giving them names that automatically cast a shadow of guilt and suspicion over them makes them more susceptible to harassment and discriminatory practices. Now that the word thug has taken on a new meaning, white folks who now call black kids thugs and young men like Richard Sherman thugs are really saying we don’t care how smart and educated you are, how much money you make, or how great you are at doing something we love, we still hate you and you're still a “N". We'll just change the word to thug.

The indiscriminate labeling of black males as thugs has created an atmosphere of disdain and insensitivity and has made them targets of crime with very slim chances that they will get justice, compassion and least of all protection under the law. In the name of neutralizing so-called thugs, police have been allowed to shoot and kill unarmed black men like Oscar Grant and trigger happy citizens have been allowed to get away with with murdering unarmed children like Trayvon Martin.

The reality is that most people who subscribe to this white supremacist ideology don't believe that Richard Sherman is a thug, but they do want him to be guilty of something because that would reinforce the negative raciest stereotypes of young black males that they hold onto to feel better about themselves. Richard Sherman is not guilty of being a thug. He is guilty of being something much more dangerous. He's guilty of making certain white people uncomfortable. He is young, black, rich, educated, and cocky, feels he is the best, and is the best at what he does. But worst of all he is not afraid to let the world know. That is why in many ways Richard Sherman simultaneously represents the American dream and the American nightmare. He has the bravado, drive, and leadership abilities that are often touted as quintessentially American BUT one of America's greatest fears is for one of its black athlete's (i.e. Mohamed Ali, Jim Brown, Paul Robeson ) to use their influence and platform to speak out against injustice and inequality. Richard Sherman has the potential to be that athlete. If they neutralize him with the "T" word before he recognizes his true potential then their fears will be put to rest - for now. So be careful not to think too much of yourself or you might be the next “N” Word, I mean thug.